The recent implementation of the zero bail policy in Los Angeles County has reignited the ongoing debate about the role of cash bail in the justice system. While supporters believe it is a necessary step towards a fairer system, critics fear that it may come at the expense of public safety. Only time will tell how this policy will ultimately impact the county and its residents. The new permanent policy has sparked intense debate among residents and officials.
Proponents of the zero bail system argue that it is a step towards a fairer and more equal justice system. They point out that under the old system, wealthy individuals accused of serious crimes could quickly post bail and be free while awaiting trial, while low-income individuals charged with minor offenses would languish in jail simply because they couldn't afford bail. This created an apparent disparity and violated the constitutional rights of the poor.
The new system aims to rectify this imbalance by doing away with cash bail. Instead, most non-violent or non-serious offenders would be cited and released until their trial date. Only those suspected of serious crimes or posing a danger to society would be referred to a judge, who could decide whether to keep them in custody or release them with electronic monitoring.
However, critics of the policy express concerns about public safety. They argue that releasing more individuals without bail could potentially increase the risk of reoffending and undermine public and victims' confidence in the justice system. Sheriff Robert Luna is particularly critical of the changes, worrying that it could demoralize deputies who make arrests only to quickly see the suspects back on the streets.
Supporters, on the other hand, dismiss these concerns as misinformation. They argue that studies have shown that pretrial detention actually increases the likelihood of re-arrest and that moving away from a money-based bail system does not increase crime rates. County Supervisor Holly Mitchell also pushes back against the criticisms, emphasizing that zero bail does not mean criminals are escaping punishment for their offenses. She warns against conflating zero bail with a lack of accountability.
Source: Youtube
